You can edit almost every page by Creating an account and confirming your email.

1871 Philadelphia elections

From EverybodyWiki Bios & Wiki

1871 Philadelphia municipal and county elections
← 1870 October 10, 1871 1872 →

The 1871 Philadelphia elections, held on October 10, 1871, involved contests for mayor and other citywide municipal offices, city council, as well as various Philadelphia County offices. It coincided with several statewide elections. After victories in several races during the city's previous elections, the Democratic Party was handed a landslide defeat by the Republican Party. Republicans won all citywide office, as well as supermajorities in both city council chambers.

Overview and general details

Background

The City of Philadelphia and County of Philadelphia were consolidated under the 1854 Act of Consolidation. However, several remaining county government offices would not formally merge with municipal offices until 1952.[citation needed]

In 1869, _____ Democrats experienced success winning both the elections for mayor and district attorney.

The October 1871 election marked the first in Philadelphia since the ratification of the Fifteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. https://www.phila.gov/posts/kenney/2016-02-02-octavius-v-catto/

Party nominating conventions

Ahead of the elections, separate Republican nominating conventions for various offices convened at several locations on June 14. In total, 84 different conventions were held to select Republican nominees for the offices to be contested in October.[1] On June 28, the local Democratic Party held separate nominating conventions at several locations for the various offices to be contested.[2]

Electoral violence

File:Octavius Catto.jpg
Octavius Catto, an African American civil rights activist who was assassinated in the electoral violence that occurred

[3] https://hiddencityphila.org/2019/11/honoring-universal-suffrage-the-election-day-riots-of-1871/

https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/essays/bloody-fifth-ward/

assassination of Octavius Catto https://www.zinnedproject.org/news/tdih/octavius-catto-killed-on-election-day-in-philadelphia/

[4] https://www.nps.gov/people/octavius-catto.htm

https://www.newspapers.com/image/167868914

https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/essays/murder-of-octavius-catto/

https://metrophiladelphia.com/history-column-philly-elections/

https://www.inquirer.com/news/winning-right-vote-heavy-price-20100914.html

[5]

Caroline Burnham's attempt to vote

As the election preceded the 1920 ratification of the Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, women lacked suffrage in Pennsylvania. Nevertheless, Caroline Burnham attempted vote in Philadelphia in the October 10 election.[6]

Burnham brought a legal challenge to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, where her appeal was denied.[7] Her arguments about what made someone a citizen and what their rights should be were collected and published by the Citizen's Suffrage Association of Philadelphia.[7][8]



https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/april-04/ https://www.loc.gov/item/04033078/

Overview of results

In the 1871 municipal and county election, Democrats were handed a landslide defeat by the Republican Party, who won all citywide offices as well as supermajorities in both city council chambers.[9][10]

Coinciding Philadelphia state elections

The election coincided with the state elections in Pennsylvania (including for U.S. House of Representatives, state senate, state house, auditor general, surveyor general, and on the question of whether to convene a state constitutional convention).[11]https://www.newspapers.com/image/952165966 ______ Republicans were successful in the statewide elections.[12] In the state's U.S. House elections, Republicans saw victories by thirteen Republicans and five Democrats.[12] The Harrisburg Patriot (a major Democratic-aligned Pennsylvania newspaper) described the October 1871 elections in the state as a "calamitous defeat" for the Democratic Party.[12] Republicans won ______

In the statewide races for auditor general and surveyor general, Philadelphia voters voted for the Republican nominees by significant margins.[10] In the city of Philadelphia, 96.98% of votes on the question of calling a state constitutional convention were in support of calling a convention.[13] The statewide result on this question was _____________ ____ In the state legislative races _____ [14][15] Republican nominees won both of the two elections held for state senate seats representing parts of Philadelphia.[10]

Other coinciding elections in the United States

Several other states held elections in October 1871, including in Iowa (gubernatorial, state senate, and state house elections), in Ohio (including for governor), and in Texas (U.S. congressional elections), and Rhode Island (which held votes on several proposed state constitutional amendments). The Republican Party's success in Pennsylvania was not isolated, with elections in other states similarly seeing improved results for the Republican Party compared to 1870 elections. https://www.newspapers.com/image/349797804 , with pronounced Republican victories occurring in Iowa and Ohio.[12]

Other counties and cities in Philadelphia also held local elections on October 10.

Mayor

1871 Philadelphia mayoral election
← 1868 October 10, 1871 1874 →
  File:William Stokley.jpg
Nominee William S. Stokley James S. Biddle
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 58,508 50,307
Percentage 53.77% 46.23%

Mayor before election

Daniel M. Fox
Democratic

Elected Mayor

William S. Stokley
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia mayoral election saw the election of Republican nominee William S. Stokley.

Democratic and Citizens Reform nominations of Biddle

The local Democratic Party held its mayoral nominating convention at Washington Hall (at the intersection of Eighth Street and Spring Garden Street).[2] The two names entered in the balloting for the mayoral nomination included James Stokes Biddle[2] (president of the Lehigh and Susquehanna Railroad Company)[16] and James B. Nicholson. However, a letter was read from Nicholson asking to be withdrawn from consideration, which resulted in Biddle being unanimously nominated.[2] Biddle received an additional nomination by the Citizens Reform ticket.[17]

Republican nomination of Stokley

The local Republican Party's mayoral nominating convention was held at National Hall on June 14.[1] The party nominated Select Council President William S. Stokley,[18] who worked professionally as a federal assessor.[16] Throughout 1871, Stokley publicly distanced himself from controversial votes taken by the city's Public Buildings Commission (which, as Select Council president, he was an ex officio member of).[18]

Stokley was nominated in a single round of balloting, receiving 246 delegate votes. M. Hall Stanton received 82 delegate votes, while two other candidates that had been entered for balloting received 7 and 0 votes. A motion was thereafter passed to make Stokley's nomination unanimous.[19]

Results

1871 Philadelphia mayoral election[12][20][21]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican William S. Stokley 58,508 53.77%
Democratic James S. Biddle 50,307 46.23%
Total votes 108,815 100
Results by ward[20]
Ward Stokley Biddle Total
# % # % #
1st % %
2nd % %
3rd % %
4th % %
5th % %
6th % %
7th % %
8th % %
9th % %
10th % %
11th % %
12th % %
13th % %
14th % %
15th % %
16th % %
17th % %
18th % %
19th % %
21st % %
22nd % %
23rd % %
24th % %
25th % %
26th % %
27th % %
28th % %
29th % %
Total % %

District attorney

1871 Philadelphia District Attorney election
← 1868 October 10, 1871 1874 →
  File:William Benson Mann by E. F. L. Randolph (crop 1).png
Nominee William B. Mann Furman Sheppard
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 54,044 52,809
Percentage 50.58% 49.42%

District Attorney before election

Furman Sheppard
Democratic

Elected District Attorney

William B. Mann
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia District Attorney election saw the election of Republican nominee William B. Mann, who unseated incumbent Democrat Furman Sheppard.

Background

The incumbent district attorney was Democrat Furman Sheppard, who had been elected in 1868 to succeed William B. Mann. However, after Sheppard first assumed the office, his 1868 Republican opponent Charles Gibbons successfully contested the result of the election, and was declared the rightful victor. Subsequently, in 1870 a court ruled there had been a tabulation error and that Sheppard (not Gibbons) had indeed won the 1868 election, and Sheppard was re-installed as district attorney.[22]

Democratic and Citizens Reform nominations of Sheppard

The local Democratic Party's nominating convention for the office of District Attorney met on June 28 at National Hall. Furman Shepard was unanimously re-nominated for the office.[2] Shepard was a lawyer by profession. He received an additional nomination on the Citizens Reform ticket.[16]

Republican nomination of Mann

The local Republican Party's nominating convention for district attorney met at the newly-opened court house on the block of Sixth Street below Chestnut Street.[1]

The two names placed for balloting were William B. Mann[1] (a lawyer[16] and the former district attorney[citation needed]) and Moses A. Dropsie. Mann secured the nomination the first ballot, with 307 delegate votes to Dropsie's 22. After this, a motion massed to make the nomination of Mann unanimous.[1][23]

Results

1871 Philadelphia district attorney election[9]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican William B. Mann[24] 54,044 50.58
Democratic Furman Sheppard[25] (incumbent) 52,809 49.42
Total votes 106,853 100
Results by ward[20]
Ward Mann Sheppard Total
# % # % #
1st % %
2nd % %
3rd % %
4th % %
5th % %
6th % %
7th % %
8th % %
9th % %
11th % %
12th % %
13th % %
14th % %
15th % %
16th % %
17th % %
18th % %
19th % %
21st % %
22nd % %
23rd % %
24th % %
25th % %
26th % %
27th % %
28th % %
29th % %
Total % %

Treasurer

1871 Philadelphia treasurer election
← 1869[26] October 10, 1871 1873 →
  File:Pabwidener (crop1).jpg
Nominee Peter Arrell Browne Widener S. Gross Fry
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 59,061 49,184
Percentage 54.32% 45.24%

Treasurer before election

Joseph F. Marcer
Republican

Elected Treasurer

Peter Arrell Browne Widener
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia city treasurer election saw the election of Republican nominee Peter Arrell Browne Widener.

Democratic nomination of Fry

The local Democratic Party's nominating convention for the office of city treasurer was held at the Assembly Buildings on June 28. S. Gross Fry[2] (a railroad president[16]), Simon W. Arnold, and Malcolm Campbell's names were placed into balloting. Fry won the nomination on the single ballot, receiving 48 delegate votes to Arnold's 20 and Campbell's 19. A motion was then passed to declare Fry's nomination unanimous.[2]

Republican nomination of Widner

The local Republican Party's nominating convention for city treasurer met June 14 at the Concert Hall.[1][27] Four names were entered for balloting: Alexander M. Fox, Peter Arrell Browne Widener[27] (a butcher)[16], David Jones, and Peter Lane Jr.[27] (an assistant federal assessor).[28] Widener was nominated on the fourth ballot.[27]

Republican convention balloting[27]
Candidate 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
Widener 105 112 154 224
Fox 83 77 102 104
Lane 83 79 66 N/A
Jones 65 65 N/A N/A

Campaign

The outgoing treasurer, Republican Joseph F. Marcer, _____[29] _____ Great Chicago Fire _____


Charles Yerkes arrest in late October https://www.newspapers.com/image/843835163 https://www.jstor.org/stable/20090946?seq=1

Marcer conviction https://www.newspapers.com/image/663177307 https://www.nytimes.com/1872/02/13/archives/justice-in-philadelphia-two-municipal-defaulters-sent-to-the.html

Results

1871 Philadelphia city treasurer election[30]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican Peter Arrell Browne Widener 59,061 54.32
Democratic S. Gross Fry[25] 49,184 45.24
Citizens Reform Henry Perkins[17] 3482 3.20
Total votes 108,727 100
Results by ward[30]
Ward Widener Fry Perkins Total
# % # % # % #
1st % % %
2nd % % %
3rd % % %
4th % % %
5th % % %
6th % % %
7th % % %
8th % % %
9th % % %
11th % % %
12th % % %
13th % % %
14th % % %
15th % % %
16th % % %
17th % % %
18th % % %
19th % % %
21st % % %
22nd % % %
23rd % % %
24th % % %
25th % % %
26th % % %
27th % % %
28th % % %
29th % % %
Total % % %

Solicitor

1871 Philadelphia solicitor election
← 1868[31] October 10, 1871 1874 →
  File:Charles HT Collis (3x4).jpg
Nominee Charles H. T. Collis Thomas J. Barger
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 58,916 49,014
Percentage 52.88% 44.00%

Solicitor before election

Thomas J. Worrell
Republican

Elected Solicitor

Charles H. T. Collis
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia solicitor election saw the election of Republican nominee Charles H. T. Collis.

Democratic nomination of Barger

https://www.newspapers.com/image/85299961

Barger was a lawyer[16]

Republican nomination of Collis

The local Republican Party's nominating convention for city solicitor was held at the Court of Common Pleas courtroom on June 14. [1] Name entered for nomination were Thomas J. Worrell[32] (the incumbent),[33][32] and Charles H. T. Collis[32] (a lawyer and former general)[16][9], and John C. Redheffer. Collis secured the nomination on the first ballot, receiving 223 delegate votes while Worrell received 87 and Redheffer received 16. Afterwards, a motion was adopted to make the nomination unanimous.[32]

Citizens Reform nomination of Hollis

The Citizens Reform candidate ran a contender of their own in this election, nominating lawyer Edward Hopper.[16]

Results

1871 Philadelphia city solicitor election[9][34]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican Charles H. T. Collis[24] 58,916 52.88
Democratic Thomas J. Barger[25] 49,014 44.00
Citizens Reform Edward Hopper[17] 3474 3.12
Total votes 111,404 100
Results by ward[34]
Ward Collis Barger Hopper Total
# % # % # % #
1st % % %
2nd % % %
3rd % % %
4th % % %
5th % % %
6th % % %
7th % % %
8th % % %
9th % % %
11th % % %
12th % % %
13th % % %
14th % % %
15th % % %
16th % % %
17th % % %
18th % % %
19th % % %
21st % % %
22nd % % %
23rd % % %
24th % % %
25th % % %
26th % % %
27th % % %
28th % % %
29th % % %
Total % % %

Coroner

1871 Philadelphia coroner election
← 1869[35] October 10, 1871 1873 →
 
Nominee John G. L. Brown Judah Isaacs
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 63,826 48,225
Percentage 56.96% 43.04%

Coroner before election

John G. L. Brown
Republican

Elected Coroner

John G. L. Brown
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia coroner election saw the re-election of Republican John G. L. Brown (who was nominated both by the Republican Party and the Citizens Reform ticket).[20]

Democratic nomination of Isaacs

[2]

Judah Isaac worked as a furier.[16]

On the first ballot[2]

On the second ballot[2]

On the third ballot.[2]

On the fourth ballot[2]

https://www.newspapers.com/image/85299961

Democratic convention balloting[2]
Candidate 1st 2nd 3rd 4th

Republican and Citizens Reform nominations of Brown

The local Republican Party's nominating convention was held June 14 and 15 at Athletic Hall (on the Thirteenth Street above Jefferson Street).[1][36] _______ In addition to the Johnf G. L. Brown (the incumbent coroner,[33] who was professionally employed as a cashier[16]) other names placed for balloting were John H. Parker, J.R. Sackett, Dr. Shapleigh, W. H. Sixas, W. F. Thomas, and H. N. Uhler.[37]

https://www.newspapers.com/image/85299624

Republican convention balloting[36][37]
Candidate 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th
Brown 86 99 111 126
Sees 80 79 92 79
Seixas 52 47 45 51
Uhler 32 44 26 18 N/A
Sackett 35 26 19 N/A N/A
Parker 25 27 25 N/A N/A
Thomas 14 5 N/A N/A N/A
Shapleigh 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A

In the election, Brown also received the additional nomination of the Citizens Reform ticket.[16]

Results

1871 Philadelphia coroner election[9][20]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican John G. L. Brown (incumbent) 63,826 56.96
Democratic Judah Isaacs[25] 48,225 43.04
Total votes 112,051 100
Results by ward[20]
Ward Brown Isaacs Total
# % # % #
1st % %
2nd % %
3rd % %
4th % %
5th % %
6th % %
7th % %
8th % %
9th % %
11th % %
12th % %
13th % %
14th % %
15th % %
16th % %
17th % %
18th % %
19th % %
21st % %
22nd % %
23rd % %
24th % %
25th % %
26th % %
27th % %
28th % %
29th % %
Total % %

Controller

1871 Philadelphia city controller election
← 1868[31] October 10, 1871 1874[38] →
  File:Samuel Padgett Hancock 1406229385.jpg
Nominee Samuel Padgett Hancock Eugene G. Woodward
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 63,306 46,808
Percentage 57.49% 42.51%

Controller before election

Samuel Padgett Hancock
Republican

Elected Controller

Samuel Padgett Hancock
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia city controller election saw the election of Republican nominee Samuel Padgett Hancock (who was also endorsed by the Citizens Reform Party.[20]

Democratic nomination of Woodward

[2]


Eugene G. Woodward was employed as a clerk[16]

Republican and Citizen Reform nominations of Hancock

The local Republican Party's nominating convention for city controller met June 14 at the Assembly Buildings.[1] Names entered into balloting included Samuel P Hancock(the incumbent),[1][33] Joseph R. Lydall, and Henry S. Moore.[1]

Hancock was re-nominated on the first ballot, receiving 192 delegate votes to Moore's 114 votes. Lyndall received no votes. The single round balloting was reported to be turbulent.[39]

In the election, Hancock also received the endorsement of the Citizens Reform ticket.[16]

Results

1871 Philadelphia city controller election[20]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican Samuel Padgett Hancock (incumbent) 63,306 57.49
Democratic Eugene G. Woodward[25] 46,808 42.51
Total votes 110,114 100
Results by ward[20]
Ward Hancock Woodward Total
# % # % #
1st % %
2nd % %
3rd % %
4th % %
5th % %
6th % %
7th % %
8th % %
9th % %
11th % %
12th % %
13th % %
14th % %
15th % %
16th % %
17th % %
18th % %
19th % %
21st % %
22nd % %
23rd % %
24th % %
25th % %
26th % %
27th % %
28th % %
29th % %
Total % %

City commissioner

1871 Philadelphia City Commissioner election
October 10, 1871
 
Nominee Alexander McCuen George W. Hays
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 61,670 48,670
Percentage 55.84% 44.07%

City Commissioner before election

Alexander McCuen
Republican

Elected City Commissioner

Alexander McCuen
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia City Commissioner election saw the re-election of Republican incumbent Alexander McCuen.

Democratic nomination of Hays

The [2]

https://www.newspapers.com/image/85299961


Hays was employed as a butcher.[16]

Republican and Citizens Reform nominations of McCuen

The Republican Party's nominating convention for city commissioner met on June 14 at Concordia Hall (on the block of Callowhall Street above Fourt Street).[1]

McCuen was the incumbent,[33] and worked as a liquor dealer.[16]


[40]

McCuen also received nomination on the Citizens Reform ticket.[20]

Results

1871 Philadelphia county commissioner election[20]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican Alexander McCuen (incumbent)[33] 61,670 55.84
Democratic George W. Hays[25] 48,670 44.07
Total votes 110,340 100
Results by ward[20]
Ward McCuen Hays Total
# % # % #
1st % %
2nd % %
3rd % %
4th % %
5th % %
6th % %
7th % %
8th % %
9th % %
11th % %
12th % %
13th % %
14th % %
15th % %
16th % %
17th % %
18th % %
19th % %
21st % %
22nd % %
23rd % %
24th % %
25th % %
26th % %
27th % %
28th % %
29th % %
Total % %

District court judge

1871 Philadelphia District Court judicial election
October 10, 1871
  File:James T Mitchell (3x4).png
Nominee James T. Mitchell William S. Price
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 61,235 50,874
Percentage 54.62% 45.38%

Judge before election

George M. Stroud
Republican

Elected Judge

James T. Mitchell
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia District Court judicial election election saw the election of Republican nominee James T. Mitchell .

Both major party nominees were also endorsed the Citizen Reform Party.[20][17]

Democratic nomination of Price

[2]

https://www.newspapers.com/image/85299961

Price was employed as a lawyer.[16]

Republican nomination of Mitchell

The Republican nomination for the judicial nomination was held June 14 at the Old Court House.[1][41] The names placed for balloting were:[1][41]

  • Amos Briggs
  • Charles E. Lex
  • James T. Mitchell, lawyer[16]
  • Dennis W. O' Brien

An effort was made to enter the name of the incumbent, George M. Stroud. However, the chair of the convention read a letter from Stroud in which Stroud declared that he would not stand as a candidate for re-election.[1][41]

On the first ballot Mitchell received 158 delegate votes, Briggs received 102 votes, Lex received 52 votes, O'Brien received 3 votes, and Jones (who had not been previously named to stand for balloting) received 7 votes. Since 322 delegates had voted, 163 would have been needed to secure a majority (necessary for the nomination). Since no candidate won a majority on the first ballot, a second round of balloting needed to be held. Mitchell secured the nomination on the second ballot, in which he received 205 delegate votes, Briggs received 93, and Lex received 21. After this, a motion was passed to make the nomination of Mitchell unanimous.[1][41]

Results

1871 Philadelphia District Court judicial election[9][20]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican James T. Mitchell 61,235 54.62
Democratic William S. Price[25] 50,874 45.38
Total votes 112,109 100
Results by ward[20]
Ward Mitchell Price Total
# % # % #
1st % %
2nd % %
3rd % %
4th % %
5th % %
6th % %
7th % %
8th % %
9th % %
11th % %
12th % %
13th % %
14th % %
15th % %
16th % %
17th % %
18th % %
19th % %
21st % %
22nd % %
23rd % %
24th % %
25th % %
26th % %
27th % %
28th % %
29th % %
Total % %

Court of Common Pleas prothonotary

1871 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas prothonotary election
← 1868[31] October 10, 1871 1874 →
 
Nominee John A. Loughridge S. Morgan Ramsey
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote 60,449 48,519
Percentage 53.83% 43.21%

Prothontary before election

Richard Donegan
Republican

Elected Prothontary

John A. Loughridge
Republican

The 1871 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Prothonotary election saw the election of Republican nominee John A. Loughridge.

The incumbent prior to the election was Republican Richard Donegan.[33]

Democratic nomination of Ramsey

Ramsey was a professional clerk.[16]

Republican nomination of Loughridge

The local Republican Party's convention for prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas met at Arnold's Hall (on the block of Coates Street above Second Street).[1]

Names entered for balloting were Robert T. Gill, Richard Ellis, Richard Donegan, William Read,[42] John A. Loughridge[42] (a mechanic)[16], and Lewis B. Thomas.[42]

Republican convention balloting[42]
Candidate 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
Loughridge 101 112 141 172
Gill 105 106 132 129
Donegan 56 52 41 13
Ellis 37 31 6 N/A
Read 27 20 N/A N/A
Thomas 4 N/A N/A N/A
Total votes 330 321 320 314
Votes needed
for nomination
166 161 161 158

Citizens' Reform nomination of Ridgway

The Citizens' Reform ticket nominated their own contender in the election, nominating lawyer John J. Ridgway Jr.[16]

Results

1871 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Prothontary election[9][43]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican John A. Loughridge[24] 60,449 53.83
Democratic S. Morgan Ramsey[25] 48,519 43.21
Citizens Reform John J. Ridgway Jr.[17] 3270 2.91
Total votes 112,288 100
Results by ward[43]
Ward Loughridge Ramsey Ridgway Total
# % # % # % #
1st 2,850 % 1,816 % 67 %
2nd 2,055 % 2,976 % 69 %
3rd 1,230 % 2,104 % 51 %
4th 1,078 % 2,896 % 58 %
5th 1,318 % 1,779 % 142 %
6th 811 % 1,146 % 66 %
7th 2,942 % 1,626 % 232 %
8th % % %
9th % % %
10th % % %
11th % % %
12th % % %
13th % % %
14th % % %
15th % % %
16th % % %
17th % % %
18th % % %
19th % % %
20th % % %
21st % % %
22nd % % %
23rd % % %
24th % % %
25th % % %
26th % % %
27th % % %
28th % % %
29th % % %
Total 60,449 53.83 48,519 43.21 3,270 2.91 112,288

City Council

At the time, the Philadelphia City Council was a bicameral body. Both chambers saw the election of Republican supermajorities.[9]

Select Council

upper chamber

Select Council results[44]
Ward Democratic nominee Republican nominee[45] Other candidates Total votes Party before Winning party
Name Vote total Vote % Name Vote total Vote % Name Party affiliation Vote total Vote %
3rd J. C. McCall J. Christian N/A
5th John Cochran C. West N/A
7th H. W. Galey John F. Shermer N/A
18th G. Metger William H. Bumm N/A
20th _____ William Baldwin N/A
22nd Charles H. Stokes[46] James R. Gates N/A
23rd _____ Thomas Wilson N/A
24th J. Vanhorn Henry Glass N/A
27th H. McIlwain Joseph P. Brown N/A
29th C. Binder H. D. Caldwell John Fox independent[lower-alpha 1]

Common Council

lower chamber

Common Council results[44][47][48]
Ward Seats contested in ward (total number of seats in ward)[lower-alpha 2] Democratic nominee Republican nominee[45] Other candidates Total votes Councilor before Elected councilor[49]
Name Vote total Vote % Name Vote total Vote % Name Party affiliation Vote total Vote %
1st 2 (of 4)[lower-alpha 3] James Ballenger 1,856 41.88 William Calhoun (inc.) 2,576 58.12 N/A 4,432 William Calhoun (Rep.)
incumbent re-elected
Charles Durr 1,905 40.65 Daniel M. Blackburn 2,246 47.93 ____ Potts independent 135 2.88 4,686 new seat Daniel M. Blackburn (Rep.)
2nd 1 (of 4)[lower-alpha 4] Thomas Hamilton ___ Eaton N/A new seat Thomas Hamilton (Dem.)
5th 1 (of 2) Philip Fitzpatrick W. Barton N/A William McAller (_____) Philip Fitzpatrick (Dem.)
7th 1 (of 3) ___ Saunders John Bardsley (inc.) N/A John Bardsley (Rep.)
incumbent re-elected
8th 1 (of 2) James West John C. Martin (inc.) N/A John C. Martin (Rep.)
incumbent re-elected
9th 1 (of 2) William Campbell James Vories N/A George L. Buzby (_____) James Vories (Rep.)
10th 2 (of 3)[lower-alpha 5] N/A new seat Alexander Wilson Henszey (Rep.)[50]
N/A Alexander Omensetter incumbent re-elected
11th 1 (of 1) Thomas H. Gill (inc.) W. A. Hagey N/A Thomas H. Gill (Dem.)
incumbent re-elected
13th 1 (of 2) Wilson Schaffer J. H. Kennedy N/A Abraham Kline (___) J. H. Kennedy (Rep.)
14th 1 (of 2) J. H. Carmann Henry C. Hawkins N/A W. Fischer Mitchell (___) Henry C. Hawkins (Rep.)
15th 1 (of 5)[lower-alpha 6] C. Haffelfinger John F. Glenn (inc.) N/A John F. Glenn (Rep.)
incumbent re-elected
J. Snyder Joseph W. Martin N/A N/A Joseph W. Martin (Rep.)
16th 2 (of 2) N/A James Logan (inc.) 100% N/A James Logan (Rep.) incumbent re-elected but did not assume office for new term
James Iseaubrown William T. Siner (inc.) N/A William T. Siner (Rep.)
incumbent re-elected
17th 1 (of 2) ___ N/A William H. Ehret incumbent re-elected
18th 2 (of 3) Jacob M. Davis Jr. N/A Joseph S. Allen Jacob M. Davis Jr. (Rep)
William Waples (inc.) N/A William Waples (Rep.) incumbent re-elected
19th 2 seats (of 5)[lower-alpha 7] ____ N/A Francis Martin
____ N/A Charles Souder
20th 1 (of 4) ______ ____ N/A Samuel Miller Clement Keen
22nd 2 (of 3)[lower-alpha 8] Joseph Handsberry[46] 1,476 36.45 J. C. Gilbert (inc.) 2,573 63.55 N/A 4,049 J. C. Gilbert (Rep.) incumbent re-elected
David Webster[46] 1,479 36.79 Henry W. Gray[51] 2,541 63.21 N/A 4,020 new seat H. W. Gray (Rep.)
23rd 1 (of 2) Amos R. Ellis (inc.) N/A Amos R. Ellis (Rep.) William Wright
24th 3 (of 3)[lower-alpha 9] William Keanard N/A Edward Lyster
___ George E. Hall 2,511 38.06 N/A 6,598 George E. Hall (Rep.)
___ ___ N/A Benjamin F. Stokes
26th 1 (of 2) M. Cunningham 2,274 36.14 William Bradley 2,558 40.65 N/A 6,293 George A. Shisler (Rep.) William Bradley (Rep.)[lower-alpha 10]
George A. Shisler (inc.) 1,461 23.22
29th 1 (of 2) Richard C. Lloyd 1,176 Samuel Miller 873 N/A 2,049 George Widener Richard C. Lloyd
26th ward Common Council result by precinct[49]
Precinct Bradley Cunningham Schissler Total
# % # % # % #
1st 28 14.14 50 25.25 120 60.60 198
2nd 70 26.52 99 37.50 95 35.98 264
3rd 55 % 153 % 128 % 336
4th 80 % 130 % 56 % 266
5th 231 % 234 % 55 % 520
6th 25 % 73 % 157 % 255
7th 187 % 87 % 55 % 329
8th 329 % 218 % 69 % 616
9th 195 % 230 % 88 % 513
10th 107 % 69 % 47 % 223
11th 306 % 185 % 103 % 594
12th 5 % 144 % 128 % 277
13th 209 % 195 % 80 % 484
14th 129 % 71 % 75 % 275
15th 282 % 105 % 26 % 413
16th 119 % 103 % 56 % 278
17th 89 % 62 % 31 % 182
18th 112 % 66 % 92 % 270
Total 2,558 40.65 2,274 36.14 1,461 23.22 6,293

Aldermen

Aldermanic election results
Ward Democratic nominees Republican nominees[45] Other candidates Total votes before Elected
Name Vote total Vote % Name Vote total Vote % Name Party affiliation Vote total Vote %
5th ___ ___ N/A
7th ___ ___ N/A
10th ___ ___ N/A
12th ___ ___ N/A
13th ___ ___ N/A
14th ___ ___ N/A
16th ___ ___ N/A
18th ___ ___ N/A
19th ___ ___ N/A
21st ___ ___ N/A
22nd ___ ___ N/A
27th ___ ___ N/A
29th ___ ___ N/A

School directors

School directors election results
Ward Seats contested in ward Democratic nominees Republican nominees[45] Other candidates Total votes before Elected
Name Vote total Vote % Name Vote total Vote % Name Party affiliation Vote total Vote %
1st ___ ___ N/A
2nd ___ ___ N/A
3rd ___ ___ N/A
4th ___ ___ N/A
5th ___ ___ N/A
6th ___ ___ N/A
7th ___ ___ N/A
8th ___ ___ N/A
9th ___ ___ N/A
10th ___ ___ N/A
11th ___ ___ N/A
12th ___ ___ N/A
13th ___ ___ N/A
14th ___ ___ N/A
15th ___ ___ N/A
16th ___ ___ N/A
17th ___ ___ N/A
18th ___ ___ N/A
19th ___ ___ N/A
20th ___ ___ N/A
21st ___ ___ N/A
22nd Jesse Hinkle, John K. Gamble, Daniel R. Harper, William J. Rice[46] ___ N/A
23rd ___ ___ N/A
24th ___ ___ N/A
25th ___ ___ N/A
26th ___ ___ N/A
27th ___ ___ N/A
28th ___ ___ N/A
28th ___ ___ N/A
29th ___ ___ N/A

Constables

Constable election results
Ward Democratic nominees Republican nominees[45] Other candidates Total votes Constable before Elected constable
Name Vote total Vote % Name Vote total Vote % Name Party affiliation Vote total Vote %
7th ___ Joseph Campbell N/A
15th ___ George Newman N/A
24th ___ Theodore Ramsby N/A
29th ___ John Collins N/A

Ward assessors

Ward assessor election results
Ward Democratic nominees Republican nominees[45] Other candidates Total votes before Elected
Name Vote total Vote % Name Vote total Vote % Name Party affiliation Vote total Vote %
1st ___ Robert Young N/A
2nd ___ Henry J. Young N/A
3rd ___ John Dougherty N/A
4th ___ N/A
5th ___ Hector C. Williams N/A
6th ___ George Davis N/A
7th ___ John Riddle N/A
8th ___ B. Frank Stewart N/A
9th ___ ___ Brown N/A
10th ___ Quinton Todd N/A
11th ___ John W. Woodward N/A
12th ___ William O. Young N/A
13th ___ John W. Woodward N/A
14th ___ Charles H. Williams N/A
15th ___ James Ritchie N/A
___ Henry Cobb N/A
16th ___ E. H. Havhurst N/A
17th ___ Henry Myers N/A
18th ___ William Graham N/A
19th ___ George L. Deitz N/A
___ Samuel Young N/A
20th ___ John B. Wallace N/A
___ Thomas Ford N/A
21st ___ John Lehman N/A
22nd ___ Charles E. Idel N/A
___ William T. Hopkins N/A
23rd ___ Waull Townsend N/A
24th ___ Thomas Dewees N/A
___ Jesse N. Rooke N/A
25th ___ ___ N/A
26th ___ John O'Donnel N/A
27th ___ Hiram Massey N/A
28th ___ John Knapp N/A
29th ___ James Napier N/A

Other local votes

A referendum was held in the 22nd ward of Philadelphia.[52]

Votes were also held in some wards for managers of the poor, town clerks, and local auditors.[46]

Notes

  1. Fox had originally been nominated by the Republican Party,[45] but ultimately ran as an independent[44]
  2. Most wards had multiple Common Council seats. Not all Common Council seats were contested in 1871. This column lists the number of seats that were contested in a ward, with the overall number of seats that a ward was represented by being indicated in parenthesis.
  3. Before the election, the 1st ward was represented on the Common Council by three seats. After the election, it was represented by four (with a new one being filled in the election)
  4. Before the election, the 2nd ward was represented on the Common Council by three seats. After the election, it was represented by four (with a new one being filled in the election)
  5. Before the election, the 10th ward was represented on the Common Council by two seats. After the election, it was represented by three (with both a new seat and an existing seat being filled in the election)
  6. Before the election, the 15th ward was represented on the Common Council by four seats. After the election, it was represented by five (with a new one being filled in the election)
  7. before the election, the 19th ward was represented by four seats. After the election, it was represented by five. One new seat and one existing seat (held by T. B. M. Addis) were filled in the election
  8. before the election, the 22nd ward was represented by two seats. After the election, it was represented by three seats. One new seat and one existing seat were contested in the election
  9. before the election, the 24th ward was represented by two seats. After the election, it was represented by three. Both existing seats (held by Henry Glass and Thomas Lewis) and one new seat were contested in the election
  10. George A. Shisler (an incumbent) and William Bradley (a challenger) both ran as Republicans for the single seat contested in the 26th ward. Dispute arose between them as to which had been elected. Bradley was deemed to have been elected by a select committee of the Council tasked with reviewing the matter.[49]

References

  1. 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 "Convention Day". Newspapers.com. The Evening Telegraph (first edition). June 14, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025.
  2. 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 "The Democracy". Newspapers.com. The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 29, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025.
  3. "The Murderous Democracy". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 12, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  4. "The Assassination of Catto". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  5. "William McMullen, Nineteenth-Century Political Boss", Harry C. Silcox (1986)
  6. "Caroline Burnham Kilgore, c. 1883". Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia. Retrieved 2021-02-21.
  7. 7.0 7.1 Zarro, Jennifer (2020). Making Her Mark (PDF). Philadelphia: Free Library of Philadelphia. p. 11. Search this book on
  8. Gaskell, Tamara. "Woman Suffrage". Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia. Retrieved 2021-03-01.
  9. 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 "The Philadelphia Election". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 12, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  10. 10.0 10.1 10.2 "The Election". October 11, 1871 – via Newspapers.com.
  11. https://www.newspapers.com/image/44047250
  12. 12.0 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 "The Elections". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 12, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  13. "Constitutional Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  14. "State Officers". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  15. Multiple sources:
    • "The Legislature". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  16. 16.00 16.01 16.02 16.03 16.04 16.05 16.06 16.07 16.08 16.09 16.10 16.11 16.12 16.13 16.14 16.15 16.16 16.17 16.18 16.19 16.20 "Philadelphia Politics". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 2, 1871. Retrieved 11 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  17. 17.0 17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 "Citizens Reform Ticket". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 9, 1871. p. 5. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  18. 18.0 18.1 Gillette, Howard (1973). "Philadelphia's City Hall: Monument to a New Political Machine". The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography. 97 (2): 233–249. ISSN 0031-4587. Retrieved 9 February 2025.
  19. "The First Gun". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  20. 20.00 20.01 20.02 20.03 20.04 20.05 20.06 20.07 20.08 20.09 20.10 20.11 20.12 20.13 20.14 "City and County Officers". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  21. "Mayors of the City of Philadelphia 1691-2000". City of Philadelphia. Retrieved 28 April 2019.
  22. John Hill Martin (1883). Martin's bench and bar of Philadelphia:together with other lists of persons appointed to administer the laws in the city and county of Philadelphia, and the province and commonwealth of Pennsylvania. R. Welsh & co. p. 87. Search this book on
  23. "District Attorney's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  24. 24.0 24.1 24.2 "Union Republican Ticket". Newspapers.com. The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 10, 1871. p. 5. Retrieved 9 February 2025.
  25. 25.0 25.1 25.2 25.3 25.4 25.5 25.6 25.7 "Democratic Ticket". Newspapers.com. The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 10, 1871. p. 5. Retrieved 9 February 2025.
  26. https://www.newspapers.com/image/85299244/ ____
  27. 27.0 27.1 27.2 27.3 27.4 "City Treasurer's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  28. "The Aspirants". Pennsylvania Newspaper Archive. The Evening Telegraph. June 12, 1871. Retrieved August 8, 2025.
  29. Philadelphia Inquirer, February 8, 1892 "JOSEPH F. MARCER DEAD End of a Career Which Was Strangely Checkered"
  30. 30.0 30.1 "City Treasurer". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  31. 31.0 31.1 31.2 "The Philadelphia Election to Be Contested". Harrisburg Telegraph. October 25, 1868. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  32. 32.0 32.1 32.2 32.3 "City Solicitor's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  33. 33.0 33.1 33.2 33.3 33.4 33.5 "Republican Candidates for Nomination". The Wellington Leader. June 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  34. 34.0 34.1 "City Solicitor". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  35. https://www.newspapers.com/image/168046293 ____
  36. 36.0 36.1 "Coroner's Convention". Newspapers.com. The Evening Telegraph. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 11 February 2025.
  37. 37.0 37.1 "Coroner's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  38. "William A. Winterer Nominated For City Controller". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 20, 1874. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  39. "City Solicitor's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  40. "City Solicitor's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  41. 41.0 41.1 41.2 41.3 "Judiciary Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  42. 42.0 42.1 42.2 42.3 "The Prothonotary's Convention". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  43. 43.0 43.1 "Prothonotary Common Pleas". The Philadelphia Inquirer. October 13, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  44. 44.0 44.1 44.2 "Ward Officers". October 11, 1871 – via Newspapers.com.
  45. 45.0 45.1 45.2 45.3 45.4 45.5 45.6 Multiple sources:
    • "Ward Nominations". The Philadelphia Inquirer. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 9 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
    • "Ward Nominations". The Evening Telegraph. June 15, 1871. Retrieved 11 February 2025 – via Newspapers.com.
  46. 46.0 46.1 46.2 46.3 46.4 https://www.newspapers.com/image/167866503
  47. "Journal of the Common Council, of the city of Philadelphia, for 1871". Philadelphia [Pa.] : J. Van Court, Printer. 1871. Retrieved 11 February 2025.
  48. "Journal of the Common Council, of the city of Philadelphia, for 1872". Philadelphia [Pa.] : J. Van Court, Printer. 1872. Retrieved 11 February 2025.
  49. 49.0 49.1 49.2 "Journal of the Common Council, of the city of Philadelphia, for 1872 Vol. 1". Common Council of Philadelphia. 1872. pp. 2–20, 31–33, Appendix 14–15. Retrieved 7 August 2025 – via Archive.org.
  50. "Alexander Wilson Henszey". Pennsylvania Senate Library. Retrieved August 7, 2025.
  51. https://www.newspapers.com/image/167861373
  52. "Local Option". October 11, 1871 – via Newspapers.com.

[[Category:Municipal elections in Philadelphia|1871]] [[Category:Philadelphia City Council elections]] [[Category:Mayoral elections in Philadelphia]] [[Category:1871 United States mayoral elections|Philadelphia]] [[Category:1871 Pennsylvania elections|Philadelphia municipal]] [[Category:19th century in Philadelphia]] [[Category:October 1871 events|Philadelphia municipal elections]]


This article "1871 Philadelphia elections" is from Wikipedia. The list of its authors can be seen in its historical and/or the page Edithistory:1871 Philadelphia elections. Articles copied from Draft Namespace on Wikipedia could be seen on the Draft Namespace of Wikipedia and not main one.