Disguised financing

Template:Prod llm/dated In finance and law, a disguised financing is a transaction structured as a sale or lease that is, in substance, a loan secured by the underlying asset. In such cases, courts or accounting standards may recharacterise the arrangement as a secured loan rather than a true sale or true lease, with consequences for perfection and priority under secured-transactions law, and for financial reporting and bankruptcy treatment.

Definition and terminology

The expression is used for arrangements that masquerade as a lease or sale but transfer to the putative lessee or buyer the economic risks and benefits equivalent to ownership, making the transaction functionally a secured loan. U.S. commercial law refers to this as a lease intended as security or a lease that creates a security interest; securitisation practice speaks of a transfer that fails the true sale test and is recharacterised as a loan.

Legal characterisation (United States)

Under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), a transaction in the form of a lease creates a security interest—and is therefore treated as a secured loan—if it is non-cancellable by the lessee and any of several specified conditions apply (e.g., the term spans the remaining economic life; the lessee is bound to renew or to become owner; or there is an option to renew or purchase for nominal consideration). Factors such as the lessee paying taxes/insurance or the present value of rentals approximating fair value are not determinative by themselves. If a lease is recharacterised, Article 9 (secured transactions) governs attachment, perfection and priority of the lessor’s interest as a security interest.

Accounting treatment

Sale and leaseback

Under IFRS 16, a sale-and-leaseback results in sale accounting only if the transfer satisfies the requirements for a sale; otherwise the arrangement is accounted for as a financing (the “seller-lessee” does not recognise a disposal gain and instead recognises a financial liability). Amendments issued in 2022 clarified the measurement of the lease liability in a sale-and-leaseback without transfer of control of the underlying asset.

Under U.S. GAAP (ASC 842), if the transfer in a sale-leaseback does not qualify as a sale, the “failed sale” is treated as a financing by both parties; guidance and examples explain indicators that preclude sale recognition (for example, certain repurchase options).

Transfers of financial assets (true sale)

For transfers of receivables and other financial assets, U.S. GAAP (ASC 860) distinguishes between a true sale and a secured borrowing. If conditions for sale accounting are not met (e.g., continuing control or effective recourse), the transfer is accounted for as a financing, and in insolvency the assets may be treated as part of the transferor’s estate rather than isolated from it. Market practice uses true-sale opinions to analyse recharacterisation risk.

Bankruptcy recharacterisation

In U.S. bankruptcy cases, courts may recharacterise ostensible leases and sale-leasebacks as secured loans when the economic substance shows that the “lessee” or “seller-lessee” effectively retains the benefits and burdens of ownership. Recharacterisation changes the parties’ rights (e.g., assumption/rejection vs. stay relief; administrative expense eligibility; collateral remedies). Scholarly and practitioner analyses summarise the factors used by courts, such as residual value, non-cancellability, nominal options, and allocation of risks.

Distinction from tax “disguised sale”

The term disguised financing should not be confused with a disguised sale under U.S. partnership tax rules, which addresses whether a contribution and distribution are recharacterised as a sale for tax purposes (see 26 C.F.R. §1.707–3). The partnership disguised-sale doctrine is a separate concept from lease or true-sale recharacterisation in commercial law and accounting.

See also

• Uniform Commercial Code
• Secured transactions
• Security interest
• Sale and leaseback
• Securitization
• Substance over form

References

This article "Disguised financing" is from Wikipedia. The list of its authors can be seen in its historical and/or the page Edithistory:Disguised financing. Articles copied from Draft Namespace on Wikipedia could be seen on the Draft Namespace of Wikipedia and not main one.

---