Edithistory:The Phillips Academy Poll
From EverybodyWiki Bios & Wiki
| oldid | date/time | username | edit summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1177331090 | 2023-09-27T06:02:12Z | Citation bot | Alter: template type, title. Add: magazine, authors 1-1. Removed parameters. Some additions/deletions were parameter name changes. | [[:en:WP:UCB|Use this bot]]. [[:en:WP:DBUG|Report bugs]]. | #UCB_CommandLine |
| 1175877546 | 2023-09-18T01:12:14Z | FrescoBot | Bot: [[User:FrescoBot/Links|link syntax]] and minor changes |
| 1174789448 | 2023-09-10T17:53:53Z | DoubleGrazing | just adding back the AfC rejection tag, so the status of this is a bit more obvious |
| 1173257305 | 2023-09-01T08:18:32Z | Tintinthereporter226 | |
| 1173248165 | 2023-09-01T06:28:14Z | Tintinthereporter226 | Slight rewrite of content |
| 1173001962 | 2023-08-30T17:25:56Z | Tintinthereporter226 | /* External links */ |
| 1172856787 | 2023-08-29T19:25:20Z | Tintinthereporter226 | Added short description |
| 1172852451 | 2023-08-29T18:48:52Z | Jay | minor change to avert G13 after undeletion - removed empty line |
| 1141049781 | 2023-02-23T02:49:11Z | Izno | remove histmerge |
| 1140831212 | 2023-02-22T00:25:52Z | Jfkadmirer | History merge requested |
| 1133529599 | 2023-01-14T07:18:37Z | AnomieBOT | [[User:AnomieBOT/docs/TemplateSubster|Substing templates]]: {{Cutdown}} and {{Rejectfornow}}. See [[User:AnomieBOT/docs/TemplateSubster]] for info. |
| 1133529249 | 2023-01-14T07:15:09Z | Robert McClenon | Rejecting submission: n - Topic is not notable ([[WP:AFCH|AFCH]] 0.9.1) |
| 1133409520 | 2023-01-13T17:17:04Z | Vergilreader | Addressing afd issues from previously. The main concerns were with notability. Regarding this, there have been multiple new sources covering this org since the afd. The New Yorker released a full-length feature. As shown in the criticism section, MSNBC dedicated a paragraph to the org and offered editorial on its trustworthiness |
| 1133397030 | 2023-01-13T15:53:20Z | Vergilreader | created draft in light of recent edit war |
| 1133391043 | 2023-01-13T15:14:47Z | 2600:1000:B14C:BA19:2C94:5D0B:8363:77C7 | Please discuss on talk page, and review [[WP:DISCUSSCONSENSUS]] and [[WP:TALKDONTREVERT]]. The associated talk page discussion is less accessible when the page is redirected by default. |
| 1133390099 | 2023-01-13T15:08:19Z | Onel5969 | Undid revision 1133389438 by [[Special:Contributions/2600:1000:B14C:BA19:2C94:5D0B:8363:77C7|2600:1000:B14C:BA19:2C94:5D0B:8363:77C7]] ([[User talk:2600:1000:B14C:BA19:2C94:5D0B:8363:77C7|talk]])No, there's no consensus for that from experienced, non-coi editors |
| 1133389438 | 2023-01-13T15:03:58Z | 2600:1000:B14C:BA19:2C94:5D0B:8363:77C7 | Undid revision 1133355497 by [[Special:Contributions/Onel5969|Onel5969]] ([[User talk:Onel5969|talk]]) Please discuss on talk page first. In the discussion that originally prompted this re-redirection, [[Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest/Noticeboard#Phillips_Academy]], it was established a new merge discussion would be required before merging. I'll start that discussion on the talk page. |
| 1133355497 | 2023-01-13T10:44:04Z | Onel5969 | Restored revision 1133187943 by [[Special:Contributions/DMacks|DMacks]] ([[User talk:DMacks|talk]]): Restore redirect as per AfD, same issues still apply - If you would like to attempt to create an article on this subject, please take it through the AfC process, which is the customary route in these instances |
| 1133260341 | 2023-01-12T22:59:11Z | 2600:1000:B121:F66A:ED79:1FE7:14A1:60E0 | No reason given, reverted |
| 1133259476 | 2023-01-12T22:54:35Z | Stopasianhate | |
| 1133259412 | 2023-01-12T22:54:12Z | 2600:1000:B121:F66A:ED79:1FE7:14A1:60E0 | Consensus is that the IP is a shared IP, so it’s not necessarily the same person who vandalized. The IP seemed to want to keep consistency, and stopasianhate gave no reasoning based on sources. Additionally COI alone is not enough to revert, and IPs don’t have a user page to declare COI |
| 1133258132 | 2023-01-12T22:47:16Z | Stopasianhate | Undoing revision by Phillips Academy IP. Appears to be an undeclared COI edit, as the only modification was name ordering. Same IP has had repeatedly vandalized [[Phillips Academy]] by adding mention of Alex Shieh Center of Gender Studies; Alex Shieh is chief pollster whose name was moved. |
| 1133248848 | 2023-01-12T21:52:20Z | Viewmont Viking | /* External links */ Social Media policy |
| 1133247642 | 2023-01-12T21:45:46Z | Jfkadmirer | Added official instagram link |
| 1133239418 | 2023-01-12T21:06:20Z | 198.140.203.135 | Fixed ordering of leadership. Founder is kept because reliable sources usually list Shieh first. However, when related to leadership, Chen is always first on official sources, whose preference should be respected. The New Yorker, which IP referenced, only discusses founding and never even mentions Shieh's and Chen's titles. No source discussing both founders together mentions their titles besides the official leadership page |
| 1133209843 | 2023-01-12T18:28:09Z | Lord of Essex | Undoing good-faith bold redirect. Comments in the cited AfD stated that the org was not notable in July due to limited coverage, though it could become independently notable with more future references. Since the election, new independent and reliable sources have covered the org. Please discuss further changes on the talk page.Undid revision 1133187943 by [[Special:Contributions/DMacks|DMacks]] ([[User talk:DMacks|talk]]) |
| 1133187943 | 2023-01-12T16:31:31Z | DMacks | Restored revision 1100965408 by [[Special:Contributions/RoySmith|RoySmith]] ([[User talk:RoySmith|talk]]): Restore AFD-consensus (school's article seems to have sufficient content on this topic, and at the time of the "split", nothing was removed there anyway) |
| 1132651454 | 2023-01-09T22:19:36Z | Materialscientist | Reverted edits by [[Special:Contributions/2600:1000:B106:9472:C5B:A230:1E4E:B1A6|2600:1000:B106:9472:C5B:A230:1E4E:B1A6]] ([[User talk:2600:1000:B106:9472:C5B:A230:1E4E:B1A6|talk]]): not providing a [[WP:RS|reliable source]] ([[WP:CITE]], [[WP:RS]]) ([[WP:HG|HG]]) (3.4.11) |
| 1132651322 | 2023-01-09T22:18:52Z | 2600:1000:B106:9472:C5B:A230:1E4E:B1A6 | |
| 1129489755 | 2022-12-25T17:41:29Z | 2600:1000:B113:4E32:B85B:1941:ECD4:8FE9 | Specified full length feature |
| 1129213763 | 2022-12-24T04:13:49Z | 2601:18C:500:5F0B:887:A5BA:9805:F759 | /* Organization */ fixed citations |
| 1129212129 | 2022-12-24T03:58:26Z | 2601:18C:500:5F0B:887:A5BA:9805:F759 | Reverted some edits by IP. A tweet is not a reliable source and regardless should not be externally linked in-text. Kept the point about criticism from MSNBC. Reverted edits about the ordering of names in body text—independent sources such as The New Yorker list Shieh (Chief Pollster) and then Chen (Executive Director) in reference to leading and founding the org. |
| 1129205882 | 2022-12-24T03:05:21Z | 2600:1000:B123:5C5A:48D8:FA57:36A4:A1C3 | No mention of Sabato in given citation, so removed. |
| 1129204568 | 2022-12-24T02:55:36Z | 2600:1000:B123:5C5A:48D8:FA57:36A4:A1C3 | Removed subjective qualifier "unanticipated" from the description of Cortez Masto's victory. Aside from being subjective and therefore not fit for Wikipedia, many pundits gave her a good chance of winning (538 gave her a 49% chance and rated as a tossup, so her victory was far from unanticipated) |
| 1129202795 | 2022-12-24T02:43:22Z | 2600:1000:B123:5C5A:48D8:FA57:36A4:A1C3 | Added criticism regarding the organization's accuracy |
| 1129202652 | 2022-12-24T02:42:11Z | 2600:1000:B123:5C5A:48D8:FA57:36A4:A1C3 | Fixed names of leaders to match official. The official website orders Executive Director (Chen), Chief Pollster (Shieh), CSO (Donnellan) in that order for leadership, but Shieh before Chen for founding on its Twitter bio. |
| 1128708893 | 2022-12-21T15:27:02Z | Rodw | Disambiguating links to [[WHDH]] (link changed to [[WHDH (TV)]]) using [[User:Qwertyytrewqqwerty/DisamAssist|DisamAssist]]. |
| 1128585223 | 2022-12-20T22:36:23Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1128584970 | 2022-12-20T22:34:42Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1128584721 | 2022-12-20T22:33:09Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1128583431 | 2022-12-20T22:24:22Z | Lord of Essex | /* Organization */ |
| 1128582831 | 2022-12-20T22:20:09Z | Lord of Essex | Contents [[WP:SPLIT]] from [[Phillips Academy]]; please see its history for attribution. |
| 1101218442 | 2022-07-29T22:05:10Z | EmausBot | Bot: Fixing double redirect to [[Phillips Academy]] |
| 1100965408 | 2022-07-28T15:53:49Z | RoySmith | redirect after merge |
| 1099433627 | 2022-07-20T19:18:38Z | 174.212.228.128 | /* External links */ MINOFFICIAL |
| 1099154253 | 2022-07-19T07:57:11Z | Czar | [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Phillips Academy Poll]] closed as merge ([[WP:XFDC#4.0.13-beta|XFDcloser]]) |
| 1096181951 | 2022-07-02T21:29:26Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1096158622 | 2022-07-02T18:08:05Z | Rodw | Disambiguating links to [[WHDH]] (link changed to [[WHDH (TV)]]) using [[User:Qwertyytrewqqwerty/DisamAssist|DisamAssist]]. |
| 1095774639 | 2022-06-30T08:47:44Z | MichaelMaggs | Per [[WP:SDSHORT]] and [[WP:SDNOTDEF]] |
| 1095734603 | 2022-06-30T01:48:18Z | Vergilreader | fixed more duplicate citations I missed |
| 1095733565 | 2022-06-30T01:42:03Z | Vergilreader | Removed some duplicate references |
| 1095556344 | 2022-06-29T01:50:40Z | Vergilreader | more criticism added |
| 1095198624 | 2022-06-27T00:29:49Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1095198502 | 2022-06-27T00:29:05Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1095172151 | 2022-06-26T20:36:33Z | Lord of Essex | |
| 1095162714 | 2022-06-26T19:17:56Z | Vergilreader | added another citation |
| 1095159818 | 2022-06-26T18:54:37Z | C.Fred | /* Organization */ Spelling/grammar/punctuation/typographical correction |
| 1095156765 | 2022-06-26T18:36:00Z | Praxidicae | this never would've gotten through afc |
| 1095156672 | 2022-06-26T18:35:34Z | Praxidicae | Nominated for deletion; see [[:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Phillips Academy Poll]]. |
| 1095156326 | 2022-06-26T18:33:33Z | Randyshawn | Undid revision 1095155803 by [[Special:Contributions/Praxidicae|Praxidicae]] ([[User talk:Praxidicae|talk]]) "If a page has survived its most recent deletion discussion, it should not be speedily deleted except for newly discovered copyright violations and pages that meet specific uncontroversial criteria" |
| 1095155803 | 2022-06-26T18:30:21Z | Praxidicae | Undid revision 1095155274 by [[Special:Contributions/TheLonelyPather|TheLonelyPather]] ([[User talk:TheLonelyPather|talk]]) this is an identical recreation to the last one which was deleted as both a7, g11 and g5 |
| 1095155274 | 2022-06-26T18:27:16Z | TheLonelyPather | This article clearly shows the importance of this organization (see first paragraph, this organization has been cited by multiple media sources) so no A7. I personally don't find this article's style promoting the organization, and there's a section of critique, so no G11. |
| 1095153597 | 2022-06-26T18:17:36Z | Praxidicae | Requesting speedy deletion ([[WP:CSD#A7|CSD A7]], [[WP:CSD#G11|CSD G11]]). |
| 1095153372 | 2022-06-26T18:16:10Z | Vergilreader | Vergilreader moved page [[Draft:The Phillips Academy Poll]] to [[The Phillips Academy Poll]]: More information and citations given |
| 1095153369 | 2022-06-26T18:16:10Z | Vergilreader | Vergilreader moved page [[Draft:The Phillips Academy Poll]] to [[The Phillips Academy Poll]]: More information and citations given |
| 1094279819 | 2022-06-21T18:03:32Z | Randyshawn | Submitting using [[WP:AFCSW|AfC-submit-wizard]] |
| 1094279493 | 2022-06-21T18:02:06Z | Randyshawn | added another citation |
| 1094150963 | 2022-06-21T01:51:59Z | Randyshawn | /* Organization */ fixed link |
| 1094148265 | 2022-06-21T01:32:11Z | Randyshawn | added more sources and more information |
| 1094138128 | 2022-06-21T00:11:03Z | Vergilreader | citation to infobox |
| 1094135370 | 2022-06-20T23:44:07Z | Vergilreader | Added info about founding |
| 1093830807 | 2022-06-19T02:05:07Z | Praxidicae | [[WP:AFC|AFC]] draft ([[User:Evad37/MoveToDraft.js|via script]]) |
| 1093830801 | 2022-06-19T02:05:05Z | Praxidicae | Praxidicae moved page [[The Phillips Academy Poll]] to [[Draft:The Phillips Academy Poll]] over a redirect without leaving a redirect: [[WP:DRAFTIFY|Not ready]] for mainspace, incubate in draftspace ([[User:Evad37/MoveToDraft.js|via script]]) |
| 1093828727 | 2022-06-19T01:49:25Z | Vergilreader | removed draft tags |
| 1093828586 | 2022-06-19T01:48:37Z | Vergilreader | Vergilreader moved page [[Draft:The Phillips Academy Poll]] to [[The Phillips Academy Poll]]: Some issues were fixed, and Gusfriend (original reviewer) said more time should be given. It's been almost a month since original submission, and more than two since the first article cited. |
| 1093828584 | 2022-06-19T01:48:36Z | Vergilreader | Vergilreader moved page [[Draft:The Phillips Academy Poll]] to [[The Phillips Academy Poll]]: Some issues were fixed, and Gusfriend (original reviewer) said more time should be given. It's been almost a month since original submission, and more than two since the first article cited. |
| 1091731639 | 2022-06-06T01:17:29Z | 2601:18C:500:5F0B:490F:B634:9D13:EC2 | bold formatting |
| 1091695860 | 2022-06-05T20:08:34Z | 2601:18C:500:5F0B:490F:B634:9D13:EC2 | fixed typos |
| 1091675459 | 2022-06-05T17:37:31Z | Vergilreader | Submitting using [[WP:AFCSW|AfC-submit-wizard]] |
| 1091673295 | 2022-06-05T17:23:08Z | Vergilreader | added proper citation |
| 1091572987 | 2022-06-05T03:34:22Z | 12.153.230.176 | added methodology and revised summary |
| 1089172282 | 2022-05-22T09:07:15Z | Gusfriend | Declining submission: v - Submission is improperly sourced and nn - Submission is about a topic not yet shown to meet general notability guidelines (be more specific if possible) ([[WP:AFCH|AFCH]] 0.9.1) |
| 1089171746 | 2022-05-22T09:03:14Z | Gusfriend | Marking submission as under review ([[WP:AFCH|AFCH]] 0.9.1) |
| 1089090153 | 2022-05-21T21:33:21Z | Vergilreader | Submitting using [[WP:AFCSW|AfC-submit-wizard]] |
| 1089090072 | 2022-05-21T21:32:48Z | Vergilreader | Added basic info |
